Rental Market Trends in Bay Shore, NY

What is the average rent in Bay Shore, NY?Choose another area

The average rent in Bay Shore, NY, as of June 2025, is approximately $1113 per month for all property types. Rent prices can vary depending on the neighborhood and the type of rental property. Rent prices are influenced by factors like neighborhood popularity, proximity to amenities, and the overall housing market trends in the city.

Market summary

Data is based on rental rates on sulekha.com. Last updated in June 2025.

Average Rental Price Over Time

How much has the average rent changed in Bay Shore, NY?

The average rent for all property types is $1113,which is 0% increase compared to the previous year.

2023
2024

Occupied Housing Units in Bay Shore, NY

Property

Compare Average Rents Across Top Markets

Discover how rent prices in your selected city compare to those in other cities.

Bay Shore, NYvs

$1113

Need a place to stay or have a rental to offer?

Answer a few questions, and we'll help you find the ideal match.

Get Matched Today

Post Your Space for Rent

Have a room or property to rent?

List it on Sulekha to connect with serious seekers quickly. Reach a focused audience and find the right tenant or roommate without hassle.

List Your Place

Share Your Requirements

Let us help you find the right place or roommate.

Submit your preferences - budget, location, and amenities - and we’ll provide tailored matches to suit your needs.

Get Started Now

Explore Listings & Discover Your Ideal MatchLet us help you find the right place or roommate.

Browse our extensive listings featuring rooms and rentals in popular neighborhoods across the city. Whether you're looking for a budget-friendly space, a fully furnished apartment, or the right person to share your home with, Sulekha has options tailored to every preference.

Find Rooms & Rentals

Neighborhood Rent Trends in Bay Shore, NY

Explore the rent ranges for different neighborhoods.

All types

Neighborhoods	Average rent
Blissville, NY	$1285
Ditmars Steinway, NY	$1088
Concourse Village, NY	$1059
Floral Park, NY	$850
Bowne Park, NY	$840
Douglaston, NY	$767
Clifton, NY	$739
Bronxwood, NY	$681

Average rent in Nearby cities

Explore rent trends in other markets.

All types

FAQs

Answers to Your Rental Questions

We've got answers to your most common questions about rentals, from property listings to pricing trends and everything in between.

What is the average rent in Bay Shore, NY?

The average rent in Bay Shore, NY is around $1113 per month. However, this can vary depending on the neighborhood, the size of the rental unit, and the property's condition. For example, rents are typically higher in desirable areas close to amenities and popular destinations. Larger apartments or homes with multiple bedrooms or modern amenities can also be more expensive. Keep these factors in mind when searching for a rental in Bay Shore, NY.
How many rentals are available in Bay Shore, NY?

Currently, there are 1 rental properties available in Bay Shore, NY. This includes a variety of options such as apartments, condos, town homes, single-family homes, single rooms, shared rooms and pg accommodations catering to different budgets and preferences. So, if you're looking for a place to rent in Bay Shore, NY, you have plenty of choices to explore!
What are the best neighborhoods to rent in Bay Shore, NY?
If you're looking for budget-friendly neighborhoods in Bay Shore, NY, consider these options:
- Broad Channel: Average rent is $1450 per month.
- Bergen Beach: Average rent is $1425 per month.
- Canarsie: Average rent is $1425 per month.
- Blissville: Average rent is $1180 per month.
- Hamilton Heights: Average rent is $1129 per month.
- Lindenwood: Average rent is $1081 per month.
These neighborhoods offer rental rates lower than the city's overall average, making them attractive options for renters.
What are the most affordable neighborhoods in Bay Shore, NY?
The most expensive neighborhoods in Bay Shore, NY are:
- Mount Hope: Average rent is $954 per month.
- Eltingville: Average rent is $850 per month.
- Canarsie: Average rent is $1425 per month.
- Hamilton Heights: Average rent is $1129 per month.
- Great Kills: Average rent is $800 per month.
- Hunts Point: Average rent is $769 per month.
How much has the average rent changed in Bay Shore, NY?

Over the past year, the average rent in Bay Shore, NY have increased by approximately 0%, which translates to $92 per month. This change reflects shifting market trends and evolving housing demand in the area, impacting renters' costs and affordability.
How much has the rent in Bay Shore, NY increased or decreased in the last month?

The Average rent price in Bay Shore, NY for June 2025 is $1113, which is $72 less than in May.